Journal

Why do I binge eat?

Bingeing is not a character flaw or a lack of willpower. There are real, understandable reasons it happens, and they are not your fault.

Lauren Hofstee, RD · 2026-06

You are not broken

If you binge and then spend hours wondering what is wrong with you, please hear this first. Bingeing is not a sign of weakness, greed, or a missing willpower gene. It is usually a very logical response to something, even when it does not feel logical in the moment. Understanding the why is not about excusing it. It is about replacing shame with information, because shame keeps the cycle spinning and information helps it stop.

Restriction is the biggest driver

The most common reason people binge is, surprisingly, not eating enough. When the body senses it is being underfed, whether through skipped meals, low intake, or a long list of off limits foods, it responds with intense drive to eat, especially toward the very things you have been avoiding. This is biology doing its job, not you failing. A great deal of what gets labelled binge eating is the body trying to correct a deficit. This is why more rules so often lead to more bingeing, not less.

The pendulum of all or nothing

Restriction also sets up a mental trap. When foods are split into good and bad, allowed and forbidden, eating one forbidden thing can flip a switch. The thinking goes, I already blew it, so I may as well eat all of it. That last supper feeling, eating now because the rule restarts tomorrow, drives a lot of binges. The cruel part is that the restriction meant to prevent overeating is often what fuels it.

Emotions and the need for relief

Sometimes bingeing is reaching for comfort, numbing, or escape when feelings get too big or life feels too much. Food is soothing, available, and reliable, and turning to it in distress is human. The goal is never to shame this away. It is to gently widen your options so food is one comfort among many, not the only door you can find when you are overwhelmed. That takes time and kindness, not crackdowns.

What actually helps

Counterintuitively, the path out usually starts with eating more, not less. Regular, adequate, satisfying meals calm the biological drive to binge. Letting foods off the forbidden list takes away their charge. Practising self compassion in the moments after, rather than punishment, breaks the shame to restrict to binge loop. This is slow, gentle work, and it is very possible. Many people who once felt out of control around food find real steadiness again.

You do not have to do this alone

Bingeing thrives in secrecy and shame, and it tends to soften in the light of a safe, non-judgmental space. If the cycle feels too tangled to unpick by yourself, that is not a failing, it is exactly when support helps most. If you would like to talk it through with someone who will not judge you, the introductory call is free and there is no pressure at all.

Questions

Is binge eating the same as just overeating?

Not quite. Most people eat past comfortable fullness sometimes, and that is normal. Bingeing tends to involve a feeling of being out of control, often eating quickly and to discomfort, usually with distress afterward. If it is frequent or causing real suffering, gentle professional support can make a meaningful difference.

Will I binge less if I have more self discipline?

Almost certainly not, and that belief usually backfires. More discipline often means more restriction, which is the very thing driving the binges. The way out is rarely tighter control. It is more consistent nourishment, fewer food rules, and more kindness toward yourself.

If any of this sounds like you

The first call is free, and there is no pressure to continue. It is just a calm conversation about what you are looking for.

Book a free intro call

See how I can help with binge eating.