You are allowed to change dietitians, and you do not need a reason you could defend to a stranger. Here is how to tell a bad fit from hard work, what happens to your records, and how to leave without a gap in your care.
You are allowed to change dietitians. You do not need permission, you do not need a reason you could defend to a stranger, and you do not need your current dietitian to agree that leaving is a good idea. In Ontario you also do not need a new physician referral to start with a different dietitian privately, although some insurance plans ask for one before they will reimburse, which is a separate matter. Switching well comes down to three practical things: working out whether the problem is the fit or the work, lining up the next person before you fully close the door on the last one, and knowing what happens to the notes that were written about you. Reviewed by Lauren Hofstee, RD, on 2026-08-04. The record keeping, records access, continuity of care and complaints details below were checked against the College of Dietitians of Ontario on that date. This is general information, not individualized medical or nutrition advice, and it is not a substitute for medical monitoring.
This is the part that keeps people stuck far longer than the switch itself would take. Nutrition work, and eating disorder work in particular, is supposed to feel uncomfortable in places. If someone is gently asking you to eat lunch on the days you would rather skip it, or to sit with a food you have avoided for four years, you are not going to enjoy that, and the discomfort is not evidence that you have got the wrong person. But being pushed toward something you actually want feels different from the flat, tired sensation of not being understood, and most people can tell the two apart once they are allowed to ask the question honestly. So it is worth separating them before you decide anything. Not because you have to earn the right to leave, but because you deserve to know which problem you are actually solving, so the next arrangement is not a repeat of this one.
Some of these come up again and again. Weight loss keeps entering the conversation when you never asked for it. You were handed a meal plan with numbers on it before anyone asked what your days look like. You do not feel believed when you describe your symptoms, or your history gets treated as background noise rather than as the reason things are the way they are. Your dietitian is kind but has no real experience with eating disorders, and you can feel them improvising. Sessions feel like a lecture with a homework assignment at the end. The foods you grew up with are treated as a problem to manage rather than food. You are being weighed when you have asked not to be, or you were never told you could ask. And the clearest sign of all, the one worth taking seriously: you have quietly stopped telling the truth about your eating because of how it will be received. When that happens, the work has effectively stopped, whatever the appointments say.
There is a version of wanting to leave that is not really about your dietitian. It tends to look like this. You dread the session and then leave feeling slightly steadier than you arrived. You are irritated by one specific ask that, privately, you agree with. Nothing seems to be changing, which is common in the middle stretch, because the early changes are internal and invisible before they are anything you can point to. Or the urge to switch arrives right before a step you have been circling for weeks, which is worth noticing, because avoidance is very good at dressing itself up as a considered decision. If any of that lands, the most useful thing you can do is say it out loud in your next session. It is a normal thing to bring, not a betrayal, and a dietitian who works in this area will not be thrown by it. Sometimes the conversation changes the fit rather than ending it.
You are within your rights to simply stop booking. Nobody will chase you down, and no one is entitled to a written explanation of your reasoning. That said, one short message often makes things easier for you, not for them. It closes the loop so that the file is not left open. It lets you ask for a summary of your care while everyone still remembers the details. It means the rest of your care team, if you have one, is not left guessing about who is doing what. And it stops a small, pointless guilt loop from following you into the next relationship, which matters more than it sounds like it should, because people who feel bad about leaving often delay starting again for months.
It can be very short, and it does not have to be true in every detail. Something like: I have decided to pause our sessions for now, thank you for your time. Or, if you want to be a bit more specific: I think I need to work with someone who focuses more on eating disorder recovery, so I am going to look for that. Or, if you want your file: I am not going to book again, and I would like a copy of my records, or a summary of our work, sent to me. There is no need to build a case. A dietitian who is a decent fit for someone else will accept it without argument. It is also worth knowing that the College of Dietitians of Ontario expects clients who ask for help finding another dietitian to be pointed toward resources for that, including the College's own public register of dietitians and the Find a Dietitian directory from Dietitians of Canada. Asking for a name or two is a reasonable request, not an awkward one. And if the response you get is defensive or guilt inducing, that is simply more information about the fit.
Leaving does not erase your file, and that is generally good news. The College of Dietitians of Ontario notes that a dietitian in solo private practice is usually the Health Information Custodian for client records under Ontario's Personal Health Information Protection Act, 2004, which makes them responsible for keeping that information private and confidential, storing it securely, making it accessible to clients on request, retaining it for the required period, and disposing of it safely once that period ends. As of the College's guidance checked on 2026-08-04, the retention period set by the Professional Practice Standards for Record Keeping is ten years after the last client visit for adults, and for children, ten years after the client turns eighteen. So you can ask for a copy now, or later, or not at all. If you do ask, be specific about what would actually be useful, and ask whether there is a fee for copying, since that varies between practices.
People tend to request everything, and then find the file is mostly clinical shorthand that a new dietitian has to interpret anyway. If your reason for asking is continuity rather than curiosity, a short summary letter is usually the better request: what was worked on, what changed, what was tried and did not help, any bloodwork or medical findings that matter, and who else is involved in your care. If your reason is your own record of what happened, or you want to know what was written about you, then ask for the full copy, and you are entitled to ask. Both are legitimate. You are also allowed to decide that you want a clean start and would rather your new dietitian hear it from you, in your words, with nothing carried over. Plenty of people choose that, and it works fine.
The College's guidance is that a dietitian should not discontinue care unless the client chooses to end services, alternative services are arranged, or reasonable notice is given so the person can find another provider. That obligation sits with the dietitian, but the logic is worth borrowing for yourself. If you can, overlap by one appointment: book the intro call with someone new before your last session with the person you are leaving. If you are being medically monitored, or you are in the middle of restoring your intake, this matters a great deal, and a month of nobody watching is a month where things can quietly slide. Tell your therapist and your physician or nurse practitioner that you are changing dietitians so nobody assumes someone else is holding that piece. If a gap turns out to be unavoidable, there is a plainer walkthrough of interim options on Ontario eating disorder support, and there are things worth keeping steady in the meantime even without an appointment on the calendar.
The advantage of a second attempt is that you now know exactly what went wrong, so you can ask about that specific thing up front instead of discovering it in session four. If weight talk was the problem, ask directly whether they work from a weight inclusive, non diet approach, and whether you will be weighed and whether you can decline. If the meal plan was the problem, ask how they decide what to suggest and how much of it is a conversation. If experience was the problem, ask how often they work with what you are dealing with, whether that is binge eating, restriction, ARFID, or long term chronic dieting, rather than asking whether they work with eating disorders in general. Ask what happens when you cannot do the thing you agreed to, because the answer to that question tells you almost everything about how the next year will go. You can also verify anyone's registration on the College's public register in about a minute. There is a longer version of all of this, including where to look, on how to find an eating disorder dietitian in Ontario, and if travel or scheduling was part of what made the last arrangement hard, virtual nutrition counselling in Ontario covers how sessions work by video.
Two things trip people up here. First, switching usually does not reset your insurance limits. In most extended health plans the annual maximum attaches to the service category rather than to a particular provider, so visits already used with your previous dietitian generally still count against the same yearly amount. Plans genuinely differ, so confirm yours with your insurer rather than assuming either way. Second, if your plan required a referral and that referral names a specific dietitian or clinic, ask your insurer whether a new one is needed before you start, because finding out after three sessions is an expensive way to learn. It is also worth asking a new dietitian what a session costs and what the receipt will show before you book, which is a normal question and not a rude one. Fee ranges and how reimbursement actually works in this province are laid out on what a dietitian costs in Ontario.
There is a difference between a mismatch and something that crossed a line. If you were treated in a way that felt unsafe, if confidentiality was not respected, if billing was not what you were told, or if you were pushed toward something that harmed you, that can be raised with the College of Dietitians of Ontario. As described on the College's website on 2026-08-04, complaints are reviewed by the Inquiries, Complaints and Reports Committee, which includes both dietitians and members of the public, and a complaint has to be submitted in a recorded format, meaning writing, audio, or video, with the dietitian's name, where you received care, and a factual description of your concerns. It is worth knowing what that process is and is not. The College states plainly that it does not guarantee disciplinary action, does not provide compensation or refunds, and is not a customer service or employment dispute process. You can also contact the College with a question first, before deciding whether to file anything, by email or at 416-598-1725 or 1-800-668-4990, extension 397. And you are allowed to simply leave without raising anything at all. Protecting your own energy is a legitimate choice.
Most people who reach out to me after a bad fit are apologising by the second sentence, and there is nothing to apologise for. Wanting a different kind of care is not disloyalty, and it is not proof that you are difficult or unhelpable. If anything, the fact that you noticed something was not working and did not just quietly disappear from your own recovery says something good about where you are. If you would like to talk through what happened and whether a different approach would suit you better, I offer a free intro call. It is a conversation, not an intake, and there is no obligation at the end of it. You are welcome to spend the whole call asking me questions, including the ones you wish you had asked the first time. If a call is more than you have in you today, reading about how I work is a perfectly good place to start instead, and it will still be here whenever you are ready.
No. There is no requirement to explain yourself, and you can simply stop booking. A short message is often easier on you than a silent exit, because it lets you ask for a summary of your care while the details are fresh and keeps the rest of your care team from assuming someone is still holding that piece. But if writing that message is the thing standing between you and getting care that fits, skip it. Your file will still exist, and you can ask for a copy later.
You can, and an overlap of a session or two is often the safest way to switch, especially if your intake or your medical monitoring is part of what is being followed. What is worth avoiding is running two separate plans indefinitely without either person knowing about the other, because contradictory advice is genuinely hard to be on the receiving end of, and it tends to increase food anxiety rather than reduce it. If you are seeing both for a stretch, just say so to each of them. Nobody will be offended, and it lets them coordinate rather than compete.
Not automatically. Records stay with the dietitian or clinic that created them, and they are not in a shared provincial system that a new private practitioner can look up. If you want the information to travel, you request it, either to yourself or directly to your new dietitian. The College of Dietitians of Ontario requires client records to be accessible to clients on request and retained for ten years after the last visit for adults, so the file will be there. In practice, many people find that telling their new dietitian the story themselves works just as well, and sometimes better.
Not to see a dietitian privately. There is no requirement for a physician referral to book with a Registered Dietitian in private practice in Ontario. Where referrals do come up is insurance: some extended health plans will only reimburse when a referral is on file, and occasionally that referral names a specific provider. Call your insurer and ask two questions before you start with someone new: is a referral required, and does the one I already have still apply. If you are being referred into a hospital or publicly funded program, that is a different pathway with its own intake process.
No, and I would gently push back on reading it that way. A lot of people have cycled through practitioners who worked from a weight loss framework, which is still the default in many settings, and then concluded that the problem must be them. It usually is not. Trying several people who all shared the same approach is not the same as having tried several approaches. What tends to help is being specific about what did not work last time, and asking about that directly before you book rather than hoping it will be different.
The first call is free, and there is no pressure to continue. It is just a calm conversation about what you are looking for.
Book a free intro callSee how I can help with anorexia recovery.